Export of evil from Scandinavia? (updated)
I know this post will be controversial, and I want to assure everyone that I would never generalise on the cases I describe, or invent any conspiracy theories. Yet I have found three news particularly disturbing.
What do you think of when you hear "Scandinavia"? Passionately defended gender equality, welfare state and an active role of the government in shaping social structures and educating the society. This is an important part of the Scandinavian identity, as much as I've witnessed, and of the region's international branding. Scandinavian experts are active in international peacekeeping efforts, consult governments and civil society actors abroad on gender equality, conflict management, civic democracy, social policy, etc.
However, what do some Scandinavians expect outside of their neat and comfortable countries?
* Story No 1. A Danish businessman has recently been charged with rape and physical assault. He supposedly hired a Lithuanian student as a teacher for his son, and, using the opportunity, locked her in his flat, beat her up and raped numerous times. Since she happened to have two mobile phones and he took only one away, she managed to escape to the bathroom and call the police. After the crime was publicised, more women started voicing complaints against this businessman, saying that they were previously afraid to contact the police. He would always use the same strategy - hire young women who speak fluent Danish, offering them good job opportunities. His colleagues suspect that he was also frequently making passes on his female colleagues, but went unpunished. The latest victim said he was humiliating her verbally, too, saying that she's just a Lithuanian bitch, not worth anything more than what happened to her. The rapist has some shady business in Vilnius and has allegedly fled Denmark due to some tax-related charges.
* Story No 2. In the recent investors' forum, a Norwegian businessman made a remark that Lithuania is an attractive country to invest because "Lithuanians are hard-working and don't take sick leave". This is due to the fact that employee protection is very limited, and people are afraid to lose their jobs. Therefore they wait until their diseases get unbearable. Of course, employers don't usually care about that.
* Story No 3. Norwegian oil and gas group StatoilHydro, 67% state-owned, is trying to reverse a ban on the sale of alcohol at petrol stations in Lithuania. The ban has proved effective in reducing accidents due to alcohol use - one of the major problems in the country. The company claims that its sales went down drastically, and this will result in laying off employees. Unemployment in Lithuania has soared due to the crisis, and Statoil owns lots of petrol stations. Alcohol laws are much stricter in Norway, and the company claims that the previously liberal alcohol policies were the factor that convinced them to invest in Lithuania.
What is clear in all of these cases is that the three Scandinavian employers, individually and collectively, do not treat people here as human beings. For them, Lithuanians are productive animals to be exploited for commerce or pleasure. This dehumanisation goes against everything what would be defined as Scandinavian values: respect for women, welfare state and government's active role in educating and guiding the society...
What I have also heard was that many Scandinavian experts and advisers (yet this is not proved by any scientific research or anything), who are too right-wing-radical for their home countries, were transferred to the Baltics during the post-Soviet transition. Here they could freely experiment with the most extreme neoliberal "shock therapy" policies, which have left thousands finding themselves below the poverty level, committing suicides or emigrating.
In addition, there was a famous case when a Danish company wanted to build a pig farm against the will of the community, which would suffer from the smell. As far as I've heard, Danish pig farms are of very high standards and pretty much harmless, yet in the Baltics they don't feel like they have to import the domestic practices. For one of my friends, pig farms are a symbol of degrading industrialism, which puts animals, along with people, into strictly confined cots to extract utility and then get rid of them.
Now, I'm not saying that it's some kind of policy to send these dehumanisers to the Baltics. Simply, they would never find a niche in their home countries. They would simply be arrested or fined, or go bankrupt. Labour unions, NGOs and activists would have something to say. Here, investors expect to be treated like gods just because they are foreign and because they bring money to the country.
Therefore what strikes me is not the fact that exploitation happens, or that exploiters come from Scandinavia (crime, too, happens everywhere), but the fact that, judging from the narratives (the "bitch" narrative of the rapist, the slave trader's "health" narrative of the investor and the blackmailing narrative of Statoil), these people are certain that they have some kind of coloniser's right to what they do or what they want to do.
This vicious relationship that to some extent has been developing between the Scandinavian countries and the Baltics has another side, too. It helps to ease the domestic pressures, I assume. Just the fact that the government and many other actors in these societies seem very keen on eradicating exploitation doesn't mean that all of the sudden everyone in these societies is suddenly free from the temptation to exploit. Scandinavian women have become independent and self-assertive, but that doesn't mean that all Scandinavian men stopped dreaming of being a macho. Scandinavian workers know their rights, but that doesn't mean that employers have abandoned the temptation to exploit. Governments are stubborn to disallow exploitation on the basis of addictions, but businesspeople want to exploit addictions elsewhere. Therefore certain disturbing equilibriums have developed with the Baltics. Alcohol is expensive and its use is limited in other ways in Scandinavian countries - go to Estonia! This is almost an official policy. It is typical that Scandinavian men travel to the Baltics expecting cheep drinks and cheap women. Here, they can reclaim their macho identity and let the steam down. Businesspeople also treat the countries they invest as "female" (and I'm certainly not the first sociologist to speak about that): their societies and governments have to be submissive (see Statoil's blackmailing message again), healthy to reproduce, and just happy to be picked up. Thus, employers' behaviour is another kind of machism here in the Baltics.
Otherwise, unhappy with the development of their own societies, they could probably vote out the powers behind this development.
The vicious relationship between the Baltics and Scandinavian countries (I'm not claiming, once again, that this excludes the existence of virtuous relationships) is therefore reaching this equillibrium: the best from the Baltics are supposed to go to Scandinavia (just think of the massive emigration of doctors and nurses to Norway, and of scientists to Sweden), while the worst from Scandinavia are supposed to go to the Baltics.
Acts of Random Kindness Ltd: Irish clothing startup to ‘change your world’
European social funds and the case of start-ups in France
67% in Ireland say 'yes' to the Lisbon treaty
Migrants keep coming to Seville, Spain and the rest of Europe
European elections 2009: better off being an ecologist than a banker
Young Europeans would like to be Scandinavian

Comments
It's not only Statoil that wants the alcohol ban overturned, but about half of Lithuania - the half under 60 years old.
It was only a few years ago where you could find a visa para shop or bar in every neighborhood. Now, when 11pm rolls around, you can popon down to the CASINO and get a 6 Litai beer, when you could buy a liter of beer at a kiosk until 9pm for 3.20 Litai.
Even in communities such as Antakalnis, samagon is making a comeback. Cheaper than regular alcohol, and apparently, just as safe, as there aren't any stories of deaths here. It's good to see "free enterprise" making a comeback, huh?
Here's one evil thing not imported from scandinavia - VOKES. SOme employers give these vokes out, some don't. These untaxed "grey" bonuses have some Lithuanians working for 800 litu per month, while someone in the same job at a different company makes 1500 because of an under-the-table payment. Yet everyone claims "competitive" salaries. BS. When Lithuanians do that to each other, and the whole of the EU sees it, it's no wonder some want to open up shop here, and when they do, they treat their employees better than Lithuanian companies.
About the sick time... my doctors' going rate for a nedarbingumo lapelis starts at 50 LTL. Week, month, whatever.
Mike, I'm really glad to have you as a loyal and critical reader of my blog. However, I'm sorry to say, but this time you really miss the point. I'm not talking about the various practices you mention. For the purpose of this post, I don't care whether consumers want alcohol back. And if we start the discussion about exploitation of employees, we should also remember endless stories from Maxima, textiles factories and so on. Yes, it's bad, but it's not my topic this time. What I was emphasising here is their colonialist behaviour, the idea that they have full rights to do things that would be completely unacceptable back home. And it's not about "Scandinavians vs. Lithuanians", it's all about "Scandinavians in Scandinavia vs. Scandinavians in the Baltics".
Daiva,
excellent insights. Btw, one of the first civil society actions for CSR in Lthuania was again against Statoil ...
It is interesting to spot at the same time, that the Baltics slowly become treated as a part of the Nordic region, the Scandinavian region. At the same time, we have these discrepancies within the region (if we can call it one region already).
I'd say like this: if LT would be like Norway, Sweden, even Germany in terms of laws and their application, then all these guys would have to leave LT + some Lithuanians leaving LT like now Danish & Swedish. But... government passes laws in LT differently from Swe or Danemark! More importantly: LT doesn't even try *hard* to copy the laws and behaviour of governing people from the Scandinavian countries. On the other, brighter side, LT people are genetically very similar to other North Europeans, which means that at least genetically they are determined for the brighter future if they keep doing what they've done up to now (but hopefully faster and more efficiently, with better application of _good_ examples from abroad).
This blog proved to be a nice report on situation in LT. Thanks.
The person who wrote this article, judges three countries based on three people. I wonder what the author would say if I were to judge the Baltics based on the hordes of Baltic criminals that come to our shores in Norway and Sweden (especially)? Estonians, Lithuanians and Latvians raid shops for valuables, steal wallets, steal cars, sell drugs like metamphetamine (crystal meth), and generally behave poorly. What are Baltic countries going to do about this wave of organised crime hitting Nordic shores? Baltic criminals are acting like wild beasts, exploiting and destroying our generous and tolerant societies.
*Sigh* I know that modern times require the skill of text-scanning, and I do it often, too. Yet sometimes it's truly frustrating to see comments based on something I didn't say, just because the author of the comment scanned the general idea of the entry, but did not bother to read carefully. I repeated several times that there's no generalisation and no judgement of the societies, esp., of course, in the rape case. However, StatOil is a state-owned company, and the investors are official representatives. The blog entry is there not to claim that Scandinavians as such behave badly in the Baltics. It is there to claim that those Scandinavians who do behave badly think it's justifiable just because they are Western Europeans - much welcomed investors - in Eastern Europe. On this occasion, I want to share this great book: http://books.google.com/books?id=JHm2c1jg2mAC& about the stereotypes of Eastern Europe and what behavior they were employed to justify.